In brief

Last week in the decision of Di Dio Nominees Pty Ltd v JVR Enterprises (Vic) Pty Ltd, VCAT set aside another market rent review determination essentially due to the valuer’s lack of reasons in the market rent valuation report.

What you need to know

In undertaking a market rent review, a valuer must provide reasons in accordance with section 37 (6) of the Retail Leases Act 2003 (Vic) (the Act) so that any person reading the report can fully understand how the valuer has arrived at the rental determination. A lack of properly articulated reasons is the most common ground to attack a market rent valuation.

Background

The valuer undertook a valuation of a newsagency and Australia Post in Keilor when the landlord and tenant could not agree on the rent due under the lease, where a market rent review was due. On 6 March 2017, the valuer determined a rent of $46,475 per annum plus GST, where the passing rent prior to the determination was $97,332.24 plus GST per annum. Of course, the fact that the rent had more than halved caused the landlord to initiate the proceedings to have the rental determination set aside.

VCAT set aside the market rent determination, not because the rental figure was “incorrect” but because the valuer had not provided detailed reasons, as to:

  • whether the valuer had considered the various matters set out in section 37 (2) of the Act;
  • how the valuer determined the rent at the rate determined when comparable properties were at a much higher rent; and
  • whether the valuer considered the submissions made by the parties.

VCAT also makes some comments concerning a valuer answering questions about the valuation when queried by a landlord or tenant’s solicitors. I will address this in a future update.

Conclusion

To ensure that a market rent determination is not set aside, a valuer must ensure that the report provides detailed reasons as to how the rent was determined and furthermore, also provide confirmation and perhaps include a summary of the submissions made by the parties to the valuer.

About the Author

Rohan Ingleton

Partner
A telecommunications and retail leasing expert, Rohan is a property specialist with an enviable reputation.

Related News

Valuer and Retail Leases Update – A refresher on seven steps to follow to avoid having your valuation set aside

Partner Rohan Ingleton provides some updated steps to follow to avoid your valuation being set aside.
3 September, 2018

Valuer and Retail Leases Update – Can a variation of lease create a new lease?

If you are carrying a valuation, or advising on a lease that has been varied, it is important to get advice as to whether the variation of lease has created a new lease that may be subject to the Retail...
19 March, 2018